Man Exonerated In Malcolm X’s Murder Sues NYC For $40 Million
A man exonerated last November in Malcolm X’s 1965 murder is reportedly suing New York City after it admitted to have wrongly branded him a murderer.
According to Reuters, 84-year-old Muhammad Aziz is seeking $40 million for the two decades he spent in prison and the over 55 years of being wrongfully blamed. He says the label of being guilty and the prison time caused “immense and irreparable” damage to him and his family.
Aziz is married and has six children.
RELATED: Two Men Convicted Of Malcolm X Slaying Will Be Exonerated Five Decades After His Assassination
The estate of Aziz’s co-defendant, Khalil Islam, who spent 22 years in prison and was also exonerated of the crime, filed a similar $40 million lawsuit in Brooklyn federal court. Islam died in 2009.
"They got a small measure of justice when their convictions were vacated," Deborah Francois, a lawyer for both plaintiffs, said Thursday (July 14), according to Reuters. "But we want to hold government officials accountable for misconduct that led to their wrongful convictions and decades of living with the stigma of being labeled Malcolm X's murderers."
New York Mayor Eric Adams said in a statement that the city was reviewing the lawsuits and that overturning Aziz and Islam’s convictions was the “just outcome.”
A third man, Mujahid Halim, was also convicted in the civil rights leader’s killing. He testified that Aziz and Islam were innocent and was paroled in 2010.
Aziz and Islam’s exoneration represents an acknowledgment of horrific errors made in the 1965 murder. The district attorney’s office investigation and attorneys for the men found that prosecutors, the F.B.I. and New York Police Department had withheld key evidence that, had it been turned over, would have likely led to acquittal for both of them.
The two men were alleged to be part of a trio that opened fire inside a crowded Audubon Ballroom in Manhattan as Malcolm X was starting to speak on Feb. 21, 1965. Aziz, Islam and Talmadge X. Hayer (Thomas Hagan) were pinned with the killing. Hayer admitted to his role in the shooting, but said Aziz and Islam were not involved. He said in a 1977 affidavit that he had instead plotted the assassination with four other people for Malcolm’s criticism of the Nation of Islam, which he had been separated from, and its then-leader Elijah Muhammad. Aziz and Islam, he said, were not among them.
The investigation also comes after a revealing Netflix documentary, Who Killed Malcolm X, about the assassination and a recently released biography renewed interest in the case. Neither identified who prosecutors now believe really killed the civil rights leader, and those who were previously implicated but never arrested and are now dead.
The overturned convictions also uncover the hastiness of authorities to hastily arrest two Black Muslim men on scant evidence, ironically perpetuating the systemic racism that Malcolm himself roared against.
In an interview with The New York Times, Manhattan District Attorney Cyrus R. Vance Jr. apologized on behalf of law enforcement, saying the failures of police could not be remedied, “but what we can do is acknowledge the error, the severity of the error.”
“This points to the truth that law enforcement over history has often failed to live up to its responsibilities,” Vance said. “These men did not get the justice that they deserved.”
Vance conducted the re-investigation along with the Innocence Project and the office of civil rights lawyer David Shanies. Together, they contended that the case was inundated with serious obstacles as key documents were lost, along with physical evidence that was no longer available to be tested.
Additionally, a cache of F.B.I. documents included information that implicated other suspects and pointed away from Islam and Aziz, the Times reports. Prosecutors’ notes indicate they failed to disclose the presence of undercover officers in the ballroom at the time of the shooting. Police Department files also revealed that a reporter for The New York Daily News received a call the morning of the shooting indicating that Malcolm X would be murdered.
